33 - Shut Up and Listen: Why Great Leaders Ask More Questions

The Leadership Power of Active Listening, Curiosity, and Seeking Diverse Perspectives

Why Listening is a Leadership Superpower

Leadership is often associated with decisiveness, vision, and authority. Yet, the most effective leaders are not the ones who talk the most—they are the ones who listen the best.

Great leadership isn’t about having the right answers. It’s about asking the right questions. It’s about recognizing that the people around you bring valuable perspectives, expertise, and insights that can transform the way decisions are made.

Listening is not passive. It is an active, intentional, and strategic skill. Done well, it builds trust, deepens relationships, and strengthens decision-making. Done poorly—or ignored altogether—it leads to disengagement, missed opportunities, and costly blind spots.

So, how do leaders develop better listening habits? How can curiosity become a leadership advantage? And how do you create a culture where asking questions is just as valued as answering them? Let’s dive in.

The Leadership Trap: Talking Too Much, Listening Too Little

In leadership, confidence and expertise are prized. But there’s a dangerous assumption that leaders are supposed to know everything. This pressure leads many to fall into the habit of talking more than they listen.

Signs a Leader May Be Listening Too Little

• Meetings feel like monologues instead of discussions.

• Employees hesitate to speak up or challenge decisions.

• Decision-making is done in silos with little cross-team input.

• Leaders feel like they are constantly solving problems alone.

When leaders dominate conversations, they cut off valuable contributions. They unintentionally send the message that their perspective matters more than others’. Over time, this erodes trust, lowers engagement, and leads to avoidable mistakes.

Leadership Insight: If you find yourself talking more than 50% of the time in leadership discussions, it’s time to recalibrate your approach.

The Power of Strategic Listening: Asking the Right Questions

Listening isn’t just about staying silent while someone else speaks. It’s about creating the conditions for better dialogue.

The Three Levels of Leadership Listening

1. Transactional Listening: Basic listening for information exchange (e.g., status updates, task check-ins).

2. Relational Listening: Deep listening that fosters connection, trust, and understanding (e.g., career development, team concerns).

3. Transformational Listening: Listening to uncover insights that shape strategy, innovation, and problem-solving (e.g., vision alignment, surfacing unseen risks, challenging groupthink).

Questions Great Leaders Ask

Instead of defaulting to directives, leaders should develop a habit of asking better questions:

• To encourage innovation: “What’s a new way we could approach this challenge?”

• To surface risks: “What are we not thinking about that could derail this plan?”

• To build ownership: “What would success look like if you led this project?”

• To strengthen relationships: “What’s one thing I can do to support you better?”

• To test alignment: “What assumptions are we making that need to be challenged?”

Leadership Insight: The most influential leaders are the ones who ask the most insightful questions —because they unlock perspectives that would otherwise go unheard.

Creating a Culture of Curiosity and Inquiry

If listening is a leadership skill, curiosity is its fuel.

Leaders set the tone for whether curiosity is encouraged or stifled. In some organizations, speaking up with new ideas is welcomed. In others, challenging the status quo is seen as a threat.

Which culture are you creating?

How Leaders Foster Curiosity in Teams

• Encourage dissent and debate. A great question to ask in meetings: “Who sees this differently?”

• Reward good questions, not just good answers. Recognize those who challenge assumptions and think critically.

• Model intellectual humility. Say “I don’t know” and ask for input when facing complex challenges.

• Expand idea sources. Seek perspectives beyond the usual decision-makers—junior employees, frontline workers, external advisors.

Leadership Insight: Curiosity isn’t a passive trait. It’s a discipline leaders must practice intentionally to create a culture where questioning is valued.

The Cost of Not Listening

What happens when leaders fail to listen? The consequences can be severe:

• Lost innovation. The best ideas never make it to the table.

• Increased disengagement. Employees stop speaking up when they feel unheard.

• Costly blind spots. Decisions are made without considering key risks or alternative solutions.

• Weaker leadership credibility. Leaders who don’t listen lose the trust and confidence of their teams.

Leadership Insight: The organizations that thrive are the ones where every voice has the opportunity to contribute.

Final Thought: Listening as a Leadership Differentiator

The strongest leaders don’t just give direction—they create environments where people feel safe and empowered to share their ideas. They listen actively, ask better questions, and cultivate a culture of curiosity that fuels innovation and engagement.

Before your next leadership conversation, ask yourself:

Am I listening more than I’m talking?

Have I asked the right questions to uncover insights?

Am I creating a culture where inquiry and curiosity thrive?

Because at the end of the day, leadership isn’t about having all the answers. It’s about ensuring the best answers emerge—and that starts with shutting up and listening.

This post is part of Maypop Grove’s Leadership Evolution Series—a collection of in-depth reflections on leadership, influence, and strategy. Designed for leaders navigating complexity, this series explores how to drive change, build resilient teams, and lead with confidence.

©2025 Maypop Grove, LLC. All rights reserved.